Max Heart Rate Formulas: Tanaka vs 220 Minus Age vs Karvonen
Tanaka (208 − 0.7 × age) is generally closer to measured values than 220 minus age, especially past 40, but any age formula can miss by about 10 bpm. Karvonen is not a max formula; it builds zones from your resting rate. Maffetone's 180 formula is a training ceiling, not a max.
The direct answer
If you must estimate, use Tanaka: 208 − 0.7 × age. It comes from a meta-analysis of 351 studies covering 18,712 people, and its authors argued the older 220 − age rule underestimates maximum heart rate in older adults (Tanaka, Monahan and Seals). The catch is the error. A typical individual miss is around 10 beats per minute, so the formula gives a starting point, not your number.
Two of the four names people compare are not max heart rate formulas at all. Karvonen turns a max and a resting rate into zones. Maffetone's 180 − age gives a training ceiling. Mixing them up gives you zones built on the wrong number.
The four methods side by side
| Method | What it outputs | Inputs | Fits when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 220 − age | Estimated max | Age | You want a quick rough number |
| Tanaka, 208 − 0.7 × age | Estimated max | Age | You want a better age-based estimate |
| Karvonen (heart rate reserve) | Zones from reserve | Max and resting heart rate | You know your resting rate and want zones that adapt to fitness |
| Maffetone 180 − age | A training ceiling | Age and a health checklist | You want a cautious easy-run cap |
What the numbers look like
For the two max formulas, here is the estimate by age:
| Age | 220 − age | Tanaka |
|---|---|---|
| 20 | 200 | 194 |
| 30 | 190 | 187 |
| 40 | 180 | 180 |
| 50 | 170 | 173 |
| 60 | 160 | 166 |
They agree at 40. Below that, 220 − age reads higher. Above it, 220 − age reads lower, and by 60 the gap is six beats. That pattern is exactly the paper's point about older runners.
How accurate is Tanaka in practice?
Mixed, and it depends on who you test. A study of recreational marathon runners found the Fox (220 − age) and Tanaka formulas overestimated max by about 5 bpm in women, while Fox underestimated by about 3 bpm in men (Frontiers in Physiology, 2018). Reviews of other groups rank Tanaka among the better age-based estimates. None reaches the accuracy of a measured max.
How Karvonen works
Karvonen starts with your heart rate reserve, the gap between max and resting. The target is reserve × intensity + resting (Cleveland Clinic). A 45-year-old with a max of 175 and a resting rate of 60 has a reserve of 115. At 70% intensity the target is 115 × 0.7 + 60 = about 140.
The benefit is that a lower resting rate, which usually comes with fitter runners, shifts all zones. The cost is that you now depend on two inputs, and a resting rate taken after coffee or poor sleep skews every zone.
How Maffetone differs
Phil Maffetone's formula subtracts your age from 180, then adjusts by 5 or 10 based on health and training history (Phil Maffetone). He describes it as a ceiling for aerobic training, and says the number 180 itself is not tied to a lab marker. His advice when unsure is to choose the lower number. It suits cautious easy-running; it is not a way to find your max.
What Dialed does
Dialed lets you choose. The Age formula uses Tanaka, with zones at 50–60, 60–70, 70–80, 80–90 and 90%+ of max. Resting + Max uses Karvonen. Custom lets you type each zone's bounds from a lab test or a hard measured effort. Pacing mode offers a ceiling estimate of resting rate plus 15, flagged as a general guide. Pick the method that matches what you actually know. Our heart rate zones guide walks through each, and zone 2 explained shows a worked example.
How to improve on a formula
- Run a hard, well-warmed effort, such as a few uphill repeats, and note the highest heart rate on a strap.
- Repeat on another day. If both land within a few beats, that is a better max than any formula.
- Enter it as a custom value. Do not do this if you have a heart condition or feel unwell; ask a doctor first.
Pick by situation
- You know nothing but your age: use Tanaka for max, then check it with the talk test for a few runs.
- You track resting heart rate every morning: Karvonen zones will follow your fitness. Use a seven-day average, not one reading, so a bad night does not move every zone.
- You are new to running or coming back from a break: use a ceiling instead of a band, and keep it low. Maffetone's advice to pick the lower number when unsure fits here.
- You have raced or done hard intervals with a strap: use that measured peak as a custom max. It beats all four estimates.
- You use an Apple Watch only: its zones come from your Health data and can be edited by hand, so you can overwrite them with a number you trust (Apple).
Input mistakes that skew zones
- A resting rate taken after coffee, a hard day or poor sleep. Take it on waking, lying still, and average a week.
- Mixing a measured max with a formula resting rate, or the reverse. Use one source for each input and note it.
- Treating 180 − age as a max. It is a ceiling for easy running and sits well below any max.
- Forgetting the formula's spread. A ten-beat miss moves a Zone 2 band by ten beats. If the zones feel wrong for three runs in a row, change the input, not the effort.
Sources
- Tanaka, Monahan & Seals (2001), Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited
- Frontiers in Physiology (2018), age-based formulas in marathon runners
- Cleveland Clinic: heart rate reserve
- Phil Maffetone: the 180 Formula
FAQ
Which formula should a beginner use?
Tanaka for max, with the talk test as a check. If you are returning from injury or inactive, a ceiling like Maffetone's is more cautious.
Why does my watch show a different max?
Apple Watch calculates zones from your Health data and lets you edit them (Apple). Its method is not published in detail, so expect differences.
Is Karvonen better than percent of max?
It adapts to resting heart rate, which many runners find more personal. It is only as good as the resting rate you feed it.
Is this medical advice?
No. These are general training estimates. Talk to a doctor before testing your max or changing your exercise program.